Protective Behavior in Dogs – Protection vs. Aggression

Protective behavior in dogs is not a bad thing. Many owners come to dog forums and ask how they can train their dog to be less protective, but that shouldn’t ever be an issue. A protective dog is doing what comes naturally to help – surveying his surroundings and determining if things are on the […] The post Protective Behavior in Dogs – Protection vs. Aggression appeared first on DogVills.

Protective Behavior in Dogs – Protection vs. Aggression

Protective behavior in dogs is not a bad thing.

Many owners come to dog forums and ask how they can train their dog to be less protective, but that shouldn’t ever be an issue.

A protective dog is doing what comes naturally to help – surveying his surroundings and determining if things are on the up and up.

Most of the time, owners that want to reduce protective behavior in their dogs are actually asking about how to reduce aggressive behavior.

There is a difference, and that’s the topic we’ll be exploring today.

Read on for signs your dog is protective of you and isn’t just being an aggressive dog.


Understanding Protective Behavior

A protective nature isn’t something that needs to be trained out of a dog. In fact, they’re doing their job and following the instincts that were bred into them many generations ago.

And no, I don’t mean their “pack” instincts.  More and more research these days disproves the whole “dogs are pack animals” theory that dominated dog training for so long.

Many breeds have a strong protective drive ingrained into their instinctive core by “design.” For example, herding breeds spent so many generations protecting their flocks from harm that the instinct to do so became a part of their very fabric. That’s okay. More than okay, it’s perfectly natural.

The problem most people have is having a dog that is aggressive. It’s important to understand the difference.

Protective Behavior

If you’ve ever seen a German Shepherd in action, you’ve seen the classic protective dog.

His head is on a swivel. He’s constantly scanning the area. He may perk up his ears when a new person or animal comes into view.

He might even calmly move between his owner and the newcomer to the environment. He is calm and considerate, but he is always on alert.

If no threat is perceived, the dog will go back to doing whatever he was involved with before he sensed the new stimuli.

If a threat is perceived, however, he may growl, snarl or bark – doing just enough to warn away whatever he feels is threatening the pack. This is what a protective dog does.

Signs Your Dog is Protective of You

  • Constant Vigilance
  • Immediate Focus on New Stimuli in the Environment
  • Alert but Calm Stance
  • Moving Between Owner and Possible Threat
  • Growling or Barking at Perceived Threats
  • Return to Normal if no Threat is Perceived

Causes of Protective Behavior

There really is no cause for this behavior. Protectiveness is hard-wired into a dog’s DNA. While dogs most likely aren’t directly descended from wolves as we once believed, research shows that they shared a common ancestor with the pack canines.

Wolves work together to bring down game, raise their pups, and keep each other safe. It’s in their best interest to look out for one another.

That’s the behavior we see in protective dogs. It’s their natural tendency to want to keep their family members safe.

Sometimes, though, there can be a cause behind the protective behavior: YOU. I had a friend – let’s call her Sue-who owned a pit bull (let’s call her Chi) that was just an absolute sweetie. She (the pittie) loved everyone and everything, but she had a particularly strong bond with Sue.

As a result, Chi had a very protective nature when it came to Sue. She wouldn’t growl or even bark at strangers who got too close. She’d just move her body between Sue and the rest of the world, making it clear through her stance and general warning signs that no one was to come anywhere near Sue.

While she wasn’t aggressive about it, it still scared people. So, Sue talked to an animal behaviorist. She also spent time with a professional dog trainer. Between the two of them, Sue realized that Chi’s protective nature stemmed from the fact that Chi could sense Sue’s social anxiety. Sue was sending all sorts of “I’m scared” signals when they were out and about, and Chi naturally reacted to it by assuming there was a threat.

The good news is that with positive reinforcement training for BOTH Sue and Chi, they were able to overcome this extra-protective nature. Sue learned to relax her “energy,” and Chi learned that not every approaching person was out to get her favorite person.

So, if your dog shows signs of over-protective behavior (or worse, protective aggression), you may want to check your own energy and figure out what kind of “vibes” you’re giving off.

Aggressive Behavior

Want to know how to stop a dog fight BEFORE it starts? Check out these 5 dog training tips to keep the peace between the pups!

Aggressive behavior is a far different thing than protective behavior, and it is not a welcome trait in any dog.

Whereas protective dogs evaluate situations, determining if there is any threat to be seen, aggressive dogs see everything as a threat.

They have no monitoring behavior, rather, they immediately go into an aggressive mode which can sometimes result in physical violence.

It’s important to recognize the signs of aggressive behavior.

Signs of Aggressive Behavior

  • Overreaction to Situations
  • Immediate Barking
  • Growling
  • Raised Hackles
  • Lunging
  • Baring Teeth
  • Snapping
  • Resource Guarding
  • Territorial Urination (Marking in the Home)
  • Biting
  • Crouched Stance
  • Overly Aggressive Stance (Head Far Forward, Usually Paired with Raised Hackles)

Causes of Aggressive Behavior

Unlike protective behavior, aggressive behavior is caused almost always caused by outside stimuli, be it abuse or an attack from another animal.

Although some dogs are born naturally more aggressive than other, aggressive behavior is usually learned in some way, and it can lead to very real problems for both dog and owner.

This type of behavior is far more complex than protective behavior in that the reasons are broad as are the outlets from which dogs allow it to come out.

Causes of Aggressive Behavior

  • Abuse
  • Lack of Resources Such as Food and Water
  • Attack from Another Animal or Dog
  • Lifetime Spent in a Shelter
  • Living on the Streets (Feralness)

Types of Aggressive Behavior

  • Territorial Aggression (Guarding of Spaces)
  • Possessive Aggression (similar to territorial, but guarding objects or food)
  • Dominant Aggression
  • Predatory Aggression (Attacking Smaller Animals)
  • People Aggression

Curbing Aggressive Behavior

Looking for the best way to potty train a dog? Check out our tips and tricks for house breaking Fido quickly and easily!

Protective behavior is rarely an issue but aggressive behavior is always a cause for concern and should be addressed as quickly as possible.

While this type of behavior can be scary for both owner and those around him or her, the good news is that it can be eliminated, or at least reduced.

In instances where aggressive behavior cannot be completely quelled, taking preventative measures usually serves to bridge the gap.

1. Work on Yourself

As I mentioned earlier, one of the keys to curbing aggression is to curb your own reactions. Many owners will over-correct their dog, yanking on his leash or yelling at him to stop.

These punishment-based corrections only serve to further rile up your pooch. Instead, approach every instance of aggression in a calm, soothing way.

Don’t yell or yank or do anything to further increase the volatility of the situation.

Rather, calmly remove your dog from the situation in a manner that soothes, or at least doesn’t contribute to, the current situation.

2. Desensitization

Desensitization to offending stimuli is an excellent way to begin the process of curbing aggressive behavior.

For example, if your dog becomes immediately aggressive when other people enter the room, begin to show him that new people can be a good thing.

  • Find your dog’s favorite food, and give tiny bits of it to a friend.
  • Have the friend calmly enter the room and immediately begin throwing the treats towards your dog, then have the friend leave.
  • Repeat this process until your dog’s reaction is one of looking for treats rather than an aggressive stance.

Over time, your dog will learn to associate people entering the room with something positive rather than negative.

3. Socialization


Socialization and desensitization go hand in hand. In fact, socialization is really just desensitization to new people and animals when you think about it.

  • Begin by taking your dog on walks more frequently at times when you know others will be about.
  • Keep a firm leash and a calming tone.
  • The second your dog sees another person or animal give him a treat.
  • Do this immediately before he has the chance to bark or lunge.
  • Repeat this with every person or animal he sees.

If he becomes aggressive, quickly and calmly move on. However, every time he doesn’t bark praise him liberally and give him treats.

Over time, your dog will learn that it is far more pleasant and rewarding to remain calm and receive treats.

Once your dog has learned to associate good behavior with treats, move to take him to places with even more people an animals.

Pet-friendly stores and dog parks are a good place to start. Stay at the periphery, continuing to praise him and give him treats when he shows no aggressive signs.

Over time, you can gradually work your way further in to the action, continuing with praise and treats, furthering his socialization.

Recognize the Difference Between Protective Behavior and Aggressive Behavior

Protective behavior isn’t’ a bad thing. In fact, it’s a plus. However, it’s important to realize the difference between protective behavior and aggressive behavior.

  • Protective behavior is calm surveying of a situation and an appropriate reaction.
  • Aggressive behavior is an immediate violent response to a stimulus.

Never mistake one for the other, as aggressive behavior can lead to attacks either from or towards your dog, bites, and in severe cases, euthanasia of your dog.

Follow these guidelines for recognizing the difference between protective behavior and aggressive behavior, and if needed, employ the strategies above to help curb any aggressive behavior.

Remember, the above strategies are just a few examples. It is best to seek a professional trainer to help you curb your dog’s aggressive behavior for the best outcome.

Have you ever seen signs your dog is protective of you? Share your experience below!



The post Protective Behavior in Dogs – Protection vs. Aggression appeared first on DogVills.