Do dogs remember their puppies?

Dog Moms Ask People to Help Save Their Puppies | The Dodo Mother's Day

Best Answer

While a dog's memory works differently from a human's, animal behaviorist Steven Lindsay has previously told The Nest he believes mother dogs have the ability to remember their puppies long term.

Coren did note it's more difficult for an adult dog to remember relationships from before the age of 6 months.

Dog meets her mom for first time since puppy-hood!

Previous QuestionWhy is my dog's one nail black?
Next QuestionAre newts poisonous?

Related Questions

Do Puppies remember their owners?

Do Dogs Remember Their Previous Owners? Pups tend to recognize people they know by their faces. While there is a lot of anecdotal evidence to show that Fido may recognize a former owner who he hasn't seen for a while, some scientific evidence backs this up.

Do Puppies remember their mom?

When puppies are taken too early, complete imprinting does not occur and the mother dog will not recognize her offspring. Typically, puppies begin to be weaned between 4 and 6 weeks of age, but the litter remains with the mother until they are at least 8 weeks old.

Do Puppies remember their mother?

When puppies are taken too early, complete imprinting does not occur and the mother dog will not recognize her offspring. Typically, puppies begin to be weaned between 4 and 6 weeks of age, but the litter remains with the mother until they are at least 8 weeks old.

Can Dogs recognize their Moms? | #aumsum

Do Puppies remember their siblings?

Most puppies will go home and be separated from their siblings at 6 weeks of age. However, if they were with their siblings longer, they may be able to identify them down the road. So, in theory, it is possible your dog may be able to recognize and protect their DNA when they come in contact with a sibling.

Do Puppies remember their mothers?

It is important to socialize young puppies while they are in the litter with their mother, but not to wean or remove them too early. Typically, puppies begin to be weaned between 4 and 6 weeks of age, but the litter remains with the mother until they are at least 8 weeks old.

Do Puppies remember their breeders?

While a dog's memory works differently from a human's, animal behaviorist Steven Lindsay has previously told The Nest he believes mother dogs have the ability to remember their puppies long term. Coren did note it's more difficult for an adult dog to remember relationships from before the age of 6 months.

Do Puppies remember their parents?

Human children can usually recognize their parents even after years of separation. As researchers discovered more about dog's recognition abilities, they wondered if adult puppies would recognize their parents, even years later.

Do Puppies remember their littermates?

The dogs had been separated from their mom and their siblings since 8 weeks of age. A cloth with the scent of the original puppy was placed in front of its mother alongside cloths from other 2-year-old pups. Those dogs who lived on their own could no longer recognize their siblings – by smell, at least.

8 Golden Retriever puppies meet their mom (again) on their 1st birthday

Do dog mothers remember their puppies?

When puppies are taken too early, complete imprinting does not occur and the mother dog will not recognize her offspring. Typically, puppies begin to be weaned between 4 and 6 weeks of age, but the litter remains with the mother until they are at least 8 weeks old.

Do mom dogs remember their puppies?

Puppy's Reunion With Mother Will Make You Want To Hug Your Mom. There's nothing cuter than a canine family reunion. While a dog's memory works differently from a human's, animal behaviorist Steven Lindsay has previously told The Nest he believes mother dogs have the ability to remember their puppies long term.

Do mama dogs remember their puppies?

Do dog moms even recognize their puppies if they run into them? A 2013 study in Animal Cognition suggested that dogs do indeed have long-term memory, so it makes sense that they might be able to recognize their pups. But the fact is that it depends on a number of factors, like how long they've been separated.

Do dogs always remember their puppies?

While a dog's memory works differently from a human's, animal behaviorist Steven Lindsay has previously told The Nest he believes mother dogs have the ability to remember their puppies long term. Coren did note it's more difficult for an adult dog to remember relationships from before the age of 6 months.

Do female dogs remember their puppies?

When puppies are taken too early, complete imprinting does not occur and the mother dog will not recognize her offspring. Typically, puppies begin to be weaned between 4 and 6 weeks of age, but the litter remains with the mother until they are at least 8 weeks old.

Mother Dog Reunited With Her Puppies All Grown Up | The Dodo Reunited

Do Puppies remember their first owners?

Do Dogs Remember Their Previous Owners? Pups tend to recognize people they know by their faces. While there is a lot of anecdotal evidence to show that Fido may recognize a former owner who he hasn't seen for a while, some scientific evidence backs this up.

How long do puppies remember their mothers?

When puppies are taken too early, complete imprinting does not occur and the mother dog will not recognize her offspring. Typically, puppies begin to be weaned between 4 and 6 weeks of age, but the litter remains with the mother until they are at least 8 weeks old.

Can puppies remember their siblings?

Most puppies will go home and be separated from their siblings at 6 weeks of age. However, if they were with their siblings longer, they may be able to identify them down the road. So, in theory, it is possible your dog may be able to recognize and protect their DNA when they come in contact with a sibling.

Do Puppies remember their brothers and sisters?

Steven R. Lindsy has theorized dogs do have the ability to identify their siblings later in life and can also identify their parents as well. However, this is generally only the case for puppies who spent their critical socialization period with their siblings from when they were born to about 16-weeks old.

Do dogs remember their mum?

A 2013 study in Animal Cognition suggested that dogs do indeed have long-term memory, so it makes sense that they might be able to recognize their pups. "Some female dogs who have been a foster mom are thrilled to see their pups return to visit."

Do dog remember their parents?

As researchers discovered more about dog's recognition abilities, they wondered if adult puppies would recognize their parents, even years later. Studies show dogs can recognize their parents and siblings, but whether that recognition is based on scent or some other factor is still not known for certain.

Do dogs remember their names?

A national survey by a veterinary association recently found that only 30 per cent of dogs actually knew their name, especially in houses with multiple dogs and children. But most dogs don't really know their names. They respond to habit, food or tone of voice.

Do dogs remember their babies?

When puppies are taken too early, complete imprinting does not occur and the mother dog will not recognize her offspring. Typically, puppies begin to be weaned between 4 and 6 weeks of age, but the litter remains with the mother until they are at least 8 weeks old.

Do dogs remember their owners?

If you've ever had to give up a dog, you've no doubt wondered if your pup will remember you the same way you will remember him for years. While dog memories may not work the same as ours, both scientific and anecdotal evidence indicates that they can remember their previous owners.

Do dogs remember their parents?

As researchers discovered more about dog's recognition abilities, they wondered if adult puppies would recognize their parents, even years later. Studies show dogs can recognize their parents and siblings, but whether that recognition is based on scent or some other factor is still not known for certain.

Do dogs remember their mom?

Many believe that dogs cannot remember their mothers. They will point to the fact that a male dog will mate with the mother as evidence of the dogs having no recognition of one another. However, a dog does not have morality. When the pups were placed in the room, they found their mothers 84 percent of the time.

Do dogs remember their mothers?

While a dog's memory works differently from a human's, animal behaviorist Steven Lindsay has previously told The Nest he believes mother dogs have the ability to remember their puppies long term. Coren did note it's more difficult for an adult dog to remember relationships from before the age of 6 months.

Do dogs remember their litter?

Most dogs are born to a litter, and many are not adopted together. So, long story short, whether or not your pooch will remember their dog brother or sister depends not only on how old they were when they were separated, but their upbringing, breed, temperment, and more!

Do dogs remember their dreams?

History of Dogs Remembering Their Dreams. However, we can probably assume that if dogs have been showing signs of dreaming as far back as we humans can remember, we at least know they've been dreaming for quite a while. It's also fairly safe to say that most dogs probably do have some memory when they are awake.

Do dogs remember their littermates?

Dogs are pack animals. Their parents and littermates are their first pack. So while a dog may not recognize that he's stumbled onto his long lost sister, he may do the sniff test and be comfortable with the dog due to scent memory; he remembers her smell because they were originally littermates.

Do dogs remember their birthdays?

Although dogs may not know exactly what or when their birthdays are, they can definitely tell how long it's been without something once they're reminded of it. But I think I know a way you can make it up to them, because the best way for your dog to know it's their birthday is for you to celebrate it for them.

Do dogs remember their past?

The short answer is, they probably don't. But that doesn't mean they don't remember you. Dogs may have some type of episodic memory, or the ability to remember specific events in the past. However, the same study shows that there are real limits to that type of memory for dogs.

Do dogs remember their mother?

When puppies are taken too early, complete imprinting does not occur and the mother dog will not recognize her offspring. Typically, puppies begin to be weaned between 4 and 6 weeks of age, but the litter remains with the mother until they are at least 8 weeks old.

Do dogs remember their family?

Dogs are pack animals. Their parents and littermates are their first pack. The length of time the dog stays in the pack and how well they bond with these canine family members has a great deal to do with whether they will remember them or recognize them later.

Do cats remember their owner?

Cats possess excellent long-term memories. They can recall their animal companions and the people who feed them as well as those who irritate them. Although studies show that a cat's long-term memory may last as much as 200 times as long as a dog's, cats are highly selective about what they remember.

Do dogs remember their old owners?

Do Dogs Remember Their Previous Owners? Pups tend to recognize people they know by their faces. While there is a lot of anecdotal evidence to show that Fido may recognize a former owner who he hasn't seen for a while, some scientific evidence backs this up.

Do dogs remember their parents and siblings?

As researchers discovered more about dog's recognition abilities, they wondered if adult puppies would recognize their parents, even years later. Studies show dogs can recognize their parents and siblings, but whether that recognition is based on scent or some other factor is still not known for certain.

Do rabbits remember their owners?

9. Thanks to their senses, rabbits can easily recognise who their owners are. They know exactly who's who just by looking at a person's shape, smell and voice and can always tell who their owners are!

Do kittens remember their siblings?

Although some cats do enjoy the companionship of other cats, unlike dogs, cats are not pack animals. Unless a pair of kitten siblings are raised together, they are not likely to remember or recognize each other after becoming separated. Even a short separation can be enough to make them forget.

Do cats remember their mothers?

As soon as they leave the nest, they pick of scents of their new environment. If Mom sees her kitten even a few weeks after separation, it's likely she'll see him as a stranger. Cats depend on scent, not vision, to recognize each other. For a few days after her kittens are gone, she may look for them around your home.

Do cockatiels remember their owners?

Cockatiels do have a reputation for demanding attention of their owners on a regular basis. Cockatiels can grow so attached to their owners that they may try to "protect" them from anyone who tries to come near them, such as a partner or family member, by biting or hissing.

Do kittens remember their owners?

Cats possess excellent long-term memories. They can recall their animal companions and the people who feed them as well as those who irritate them. Although studies show that a cat's long-term memory may last as much as 200 times as long as a dog's, cats are highly selective about what they remember.

Do cats remember their mom?

If a kitten is separated from his mother, it won't take long for her to stop recognizing him. If Mom sees her kitten even a few weeks after separation, it's likely she'll see him as a stranger. Cats depend on scent, not vision, to recognize each other. This can be stressful for Mom.

Do dogs remember their owners after years?

If you've ever had to give up a dog, you've no doubt wondered if your pup will remember you the same way you will remember him for years. While dog memories may not work the same as ours, both scientific and anecdotal evidence indicates that they can remember their previous owners.

Do dogs remember their old names?

Science Behind Dogs Learning Their Names. Some dogs are able to learn tons of words, while other dogs are only able to pick up on a few basic words, like their name. This means that they learn to respond to their name when it is said, not that they actually know their own name is Fido.

Do adopted dogs remember their previous owners?

For more positive anecdotal evidence that dogs can remember past owners, you can do an internet search for videos of soldiers returning home after a war. In many cases, these dogs have been left in the care of a friend or family member for years, yet the dog runs to their previous owner, immediately recognizing him.

Do cats remember their owners?

Cats possess excellent long-term memories. They can recall their animal companions and the people who feed them as well as those who irritate them. Although studies show that a cat's long-term memory may last as much as 200 times as long as a dog's, cats are highly selective about what they remember.

Do kittens remember their mother?

If a kitten is separated from his mother, it won't take long for her to stop recognizing him. If Mom sees her kitten even a few weeks after separation, it's likely she'll see him as a stranger. Cats depend on scent, not vision, to recognize each other. This can be stressful for Mom.

Do snakes remember their owners?

Snakes have a stigma attached to them for being mindless, cold blooded animals. And as strange as it sounds, snakes can be the same way. They learn to recognize their owner or anyone else that handles them frequently. And they react differently with strangers then they would with their owners.

Do dogs still remember their siblings?

Science Behind Dogs Recognizing Their Siblings. While some researchers believe a dog cannot recognize their littermates, there is some evidence to suggest this is not true and they actually can. Most puppies will go home and be separated from their siblings at 6 weeks of age.

Do dogs always remember their mother?

While a dog's memory works differently from a human's, animal behaviorist Steven Lindsay has previously told The Nest he believes mother dogs have the ability to remember their puppies long term. Coren did note it's more difficult for an adult dog to remember relationships from before the age of 6 months.

Do dogs remember their brothers and sisters?

Dogs are pack animals. Their parents and littermates are their first pack. So while a dog may not recognize that he's stumbled onto his long lost sister, he may do the sniff test and be comfortable with the dog due to scent memory; he remembers her smell because they were originally littermates.

Do dogs remember their previous owners?

If you've ever had to give up a dog, you've no doubt wondered if your pup will remember you the same way you will remember him for years. While dog memories may not work the same as ours, both scientific and anecdotal evidence indicates that they can remember their previous owners.

How do dogs remember their owners?

You may not remember what you were doing a few minutes ago. But your dog probably does. A study of 17 dogs found they could remember and imitate their owners' actions up to an hour later. "Most dog owners at least suspected that dogs can remember events and past experiences," she says.

Do dogs remember their mom and siblings?

Most dogs are born to a litter, and many are not adopted together. So, long story short, whether or not your pooch will remember their dog brother or sister depends not only on how old they were when they were separated, but their upbringing, breed, temperment, and more!

Do rescue dogs remember their past?

Thanks to semantic memory, dogs can easily remember things they learned years ago. If your rescue dog was trained before you met them, they won't suddenly forget those lessons once you adopt them. That training will stick with them even as the rest of their life changes.

Do dogs remember their birth mom?

As researchers discovered more about dog's recognition abilities, they wondered if adult puppies would recognize their parents, even years later. Studies show dogs can recognize their parents and siblings, but whether that recognition is based on scent or some other factor is still not known for certain.

Can dogs remember their past?

The short answer is, they probably don't. But that doesn't mean they don't remember you. Dogs may have some type of episodic memory, or the ability to remember specific events in the past. Indeed, a dog's sense of smell helps them recognize and “remember” you.

Will dogs remember their owners?

Sure, if it's just a day, you expect your dog to recognize your face and smell and be excited to see you home! In fact, studies have shown that the longer a dog is separated from their owner, the happier the dog will be when they return!

Can dogs remember their mom?

As researchers discovered more about dog's recognition abilities, they wondered if adult puppies would recognize their parents, even years later. Studies show dogs can recognize their parents and siblings, but whether that recognition is based on scent or some other factor is still not known for certain.

Do cats remember their previous owners?

Cats possess excellent long-term memories. They can recall their animal companions and the people who feed them as well as those who irritate them. Although studies show that a cat's long-term memory may last as much as 200 times as long as a dog's, cats are highly selective about what they remember.

Do birds remember their previous owners?

The idea that birds can recognize individual humans isn't new. Any parrot owner will tell you that Polly knows the difference between the owner and a stranger. So Stracey persuaded her adviser, ecologist Doug Levey, to design an experiment to see if mockingbirds could really recognize individual people.

Do dogs remember being puppies?

Dogs do not have episodic memory. This means that they will not remember specific events. They live in the now. There is much your dog will remember from the period of life of puppy development that, with proper care, will make your pet a good dog.

Do dogs remember their owners after a year?

Luckily, the answer is yes! In fact, studies have shown that the longer a dog is separated from their owner, the happier the dog will be when they return! So, it's actually true, even for your pups, that time really does make the heart grow fonder!

Do Puppies remember siblings?

Most puppies will go home and be separated from their siblings at 6 weeks of age. However, if they were with their siblings longer, they may be able to identify them down the road. So, in theory, it is possible your dog may be able to recognize and protect their DNA when they come in contact with a sibling.

Can Rescue dogs remember their past?

Thanks to semantic memory, dogs can easily remember things they learned years ago. If your rescue dog was trained before you met them, they won't suddenly forget those lessons once you adopt them. That training will stick with them even as the rest of their life changes.

Do Puppies remember you?

Will your dog remember you after months apart? Luckily, the answer is yes! In fact, studies have shown that the longer a dog is separated from their owner, the happier the dog will be when they return! So, it's actually true, even for your pups, that time really does make the heart grow fonder!

Do dogs remember where they bury their bones?

Unless their bones are buried quite deeply, it is your dog's keen sense of smell that will help him locate his stash. Have you ever noticed –dogs like to bury their bones in private. If you spot them while they are burying their treasure, they will dig it up and take it elsewhere to bury.

Do dogs remember where they hide their bones?

Unless their bones are buried quite deeply, it is your dog's keen sense of smell that will help him locate his stash. Have you ever noticed –dogs like to bury their bones in private. If you spot them while they are burying their treasure, they will dig it up and take it elsewhere to bury.

How long does a puppy remember their mother?

Puppies that are separated from their moms before 8 weeks tend to be more nervous and less sociable. In fact, the longer they can stay with their litter and their better mom, however, this does not mean that dogs will always have to be with their mothers to be happy.

Can dogs remember their old owners?

Signs of a Dog Remembering Past Owners. Just as humans may remember persons from their past, so too may dogs. It is the same with dogs. They show the strongest signs of recognition with previous owners who treated them well or who treated them poorly.

Do dogs remember their owners after a month?

Will your dog remember you after months apart? Luckily, the answer is yes! In fact, studies have shown that the longer a dog is separated from their owner, the happier the dog will be when they return! So, it's actually true, even for your pups, that time really does make the heart grow fonder!

Will dogs always remember their mother?

A 2013 study in Animal Cognition suggested that dogs do indeed have long-term memory, so it makes sense that they might be able to recognize their pups. "Some female dogs who have been a foster mom are thrilled to see their pups return to visit."

Can dogs remember their previous owners?

Do Dogs Remember Their Previous Owners? If you've ever had a rescue dog, you've probably wondered if your dog remembers their previous owner. Still, there is evidence to suggest that dogs can remember previous owners, particularly if their experience with that owner was strikingly good or terribly abusive.

Do cats remember their owners after being separated?

Cats possess excellent long-term memories. They can recall their animal companions and the people who feed them as well as those who irritate them. Although studies show that a cat's long-term memory may last as much as 200 times as long as a dog's, cats are highly selective about what they remember.

Do dogs remember when they were puppies?

Dogs have abilities to remember, but their memory processes are different than humans. Dogs have a strong sense of smell. When they recognize people, other dogs, their mothers, or littermates, it is likely they had sufficient prolonged exposure to remember their smells and the positive experiences associated with them.

Do dogs remember faces?

The overall results of their study indicate that dogs -- like humans and primates -- are indeed capable of facial recognition. "Dogs are able to see faces in the images and they differentiate familiar and strange faces from each other," say the researchers.

Do dogs remember seizures?

Remember, there is nothing you can do to stop a seizure from occurring, so it's best to just ensure that your dog has space when the seizure happens. During the seizure: Seizures happen when abnormal electric pulses happen in one or more areas of your dog's brain. Some dogs experience temporary blindness as well.

Do dogs remember dreams?

History of Dogs Remembering Their Dreams. However, we can probably assume that if dogs have been showing signs of dreaming as far back as we humans can remember, we at least know they've been dreaming for quite a while. It's also fairly safe to say that most dogs probably do have some memory when they are awake.

How long do puppies remember things?

Short term memory for a dog is about five minutes; cats remember much longer, up to 16 hours. Long term memory is harder to determine. We know dogs have a long term memory because they can remember hand signals and words for their lifetime.

Do dogs remember music?

Studies with dogs have shown that they can have particular tastes in music. This has been studied by playing different types of music to dogs in animal shelters. Dogs do not really like pop music and seemed to be indifferent to it. Heavy metal music stimulated the dogs to bark and become agitated.

Do dogs remember nightmares?

If dogs can have dreams, it's pretty much a given that they have nightmares as well. Without a canine mind meld, there's no telling for sure. However, the signals are certainly there for certain dogs at certain times – whining, extreme twitching, startled or fearful behavior on waking, etc.

Do dogs remember Mom?

The Science of Dogs Remembering Their Mothers. Many believe that dogs cannot remember their mothers. They will point to the fact that a male dog will mate with the mother as evidence of the dogs having no recognition of one another. However, a dog does not have morality.

Do dogs remember things?

A cat's memory is thought to be at least 200 times better than a dog's. But as any cat owner knows, felines are more selective, and remember what they think is useful to them. Short term memory for a dog is about five minutes; cats remember much longer, up to 16 hours.

Do dogs remember pain?

Contrary to what you might expect dogs will not show increased barking when they are in pain; however they are more likely to whimper or howl, especially if they are left alone. Remember, the longer your dog is in pain, the longer his recovery may take because of the side effects of pain-related stress.

Do dogs remember siblings?

Dogs are pack animals. Their parents and littermates are their first pack. So while a dog may not recognize that he's stumbled onto his long lost sister, he may do the sniff test and be comfortable with the dog due to scent memory; he remembers her smell because they were originally littermates.

Do dogs remember voices?

Even if your dog doesn't recognize your face on an iPad, they may recognize your voice. Studies show that dogs recognize individual voices, and are far more responsive to tone of voice than specific words. Some dogsitters swear their canine clients perk up when they hear their owner's voice over the phone!

Did you remember or do you remember?

Did you remember to lock the door when we left home? It is asking if you remembered something (the something may not be in the past.) Do you remember.asks if you remember something right now (at the present) even though what you remember may have happened in the past.

Do dogs remember previous owners?

Signs of a Dog Remembering Past Owners. Just as humans may remember persons from their past, so too may dogs. It is the same with dogs. They show the strongest signs of recognition with previous owners who treated them well or who treated them poorly.

Do dogs remember biting you?

All dogs can bite, and given differing circumstances, all dogs will. Although we humans regard any bite as aggression, for dogs, biting is a natural and normal means of canine communication and defense. It's actually surprising that our dogs don't bite us more often than they do!

How well do dogs remember?

When food is involved, dogs can have excellent working memories — a sort of mental scratch pad where short-term memories linger. Furthermore, dogs use long-term memories to help them remember tricks, such as rolling over on command, Udell said. Dogs may also have episodic memories.

Do dogs remember your scent?

And the part of a dog's brain that is devoted to analyzing smells is, proportionally speaking, 40 times greater than ours.” Your dog also has an olfactory memory, meaning he remembers scents long after he's been exposed to them. Even if your face were to change, your dog would be able to associate you by smell.

Do dogs remember each other?

With dogs, the scent of a person, place or other dogs will stay with them for a very long time. So while a dog may not recognize that he's stumbled onto his long lost sister, he may do the sniff test and be comfortable with the dog due to scent memory; he remembers her smell because they were originally littermates.

How long can Puppies remember?

Short term memory for a dog is about five minutes; cats remember much longer, up to 16 hours. Long term memory is harder to determine. We know dogs have a long term memory because they can remember hand signals and words for their lifetime.

Do dogs Remember Christmas?

Dogs can easily get bored on Christmas day because they are often ignored in favour of opening presents and enjoying the festivities. Remember to give your dog something to do on Christmas day to keep them occupied.

Do dogs remember fights?

Dogs that have been friends for a while are generally easier to reintroduce than two dogs that tolerate each other and then fight as a result of built-up tension.

Do dogs remember you?

There are several ways your dog can remember you, although most studies show that it's primarily either by facial recognition, or simply remembering your scent. So long as your dog has strong, healthy eyes, [the study showed] that he won't forget you." Your dog also can recognize you through their smell.

Do Dogs Remember?

Just because dogs lack episodic memory doesn't mean they can't remember anything that ever happened to them. However, as far as researchers can tell, they don't retain those memories for very long. So dogs may have short-term, episodic memory, but their associative memories stick with them longer.

Do dogs remember experiences?

Dogs don't really think that way— research shows, in fact, that they have very little direct recall. Instead, dogs have associative memory. Dogs remember people, places, and experiences based on associations they have with them. You can change your dog's associative memories over time.

Will a mother dog remember her puppy?

When puppies are taken too early, complete imprinting does not occur and the mother dog will not recognize her offspring. Typically, puppies begin to be weaned between 4 and 6 weeks of age, but the litter remains with the mother until they are at least 8 weeks old.

How do dogs remember things?

When food is involved, dogs can have excellent working memories — a sort of mental scratch pad where short-term memories linger. Furthermore, dogs use long-term memories to help them remember tricks, such as rolling over on command, Udell said. Dogs may also have episodic memories.

Do dogs remember family members?

Dogs are pack animals. Their parents and littermates are their first pack. The length of time the dog stays in the pack and how well they bond with these canine family members has a great deal to do with whether they will remember them or recognize them later.