How long can a dog hold pee at night?

How to Potty Train Your Dog in 7 Days | Super Awesome Dogs

Best Answer

We can train them one way or another, but there's only so much we can do.

Luckily, there's a general rule about how long they can hold their bladder.

Canines can hold their pee from four to ten hours.

Still, none should have to do it for longer than 8 hours.

Zak George and the Potty Training Puppy Apartment - How to Potty Train a Puppy

Previous QuestionIs it OK to give puppies milk?
Next QuestionHow do you treat a bee sting?

Related Questions

How long can a puppy hold pee at night?

The schedule teaches them that there are times to eat, times to play and times to do their business. Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours.

How long can a puppy hold its pee at night?

The schedule teaches them that there are times to eat, times to play and times to do their business. Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours.

How Long Can dogs hold their pee at night?

We can train them one way or another, but there's only so much we can do. Luckily, there's a general rule about how long they can hold their bladder. Canines can hold their pee from four to ten hours. Still, none should have to do it for longer than 8 hours.

Puppy Potty Training- The 4 Reasons It Isn't Working - Professional Dog Training Tips

How long can Puppies hold pee at night?

The schedule teaches them that there are times to eat, times to play and times to do their business. Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours.

How long can Puppies hold their pee at night?

The schedule teaches them that there are times to eat, times to play and times to do their business. Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours.

How long can a puppy hold its poop at night?

The schedule teaches them that there are times to eat, times to play and times to do their business. Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours.

How long can a puppy hold its bladder at night?

The schedule teaches them that there are times to eat, times to play and times to do their business. Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours.

How long can a puppy hold their bladder at night?

The schedule teaches them that there are times to eat, times to play and times to do their business. Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours.

How To House Train A Puppy And Potty Train Your Dog

How long can a puppy hold it at night?

A puppy can hold their bladder for 30 to 45 minutes max at 2 months old. 1.5hrs to 2hrs at 3 months old, and an hour for each month of their age at 4 months old and older. Use this as a rule of thumb and you will be closer to reality.

How long can Puppies hold their bladder at night?

The schedule teaches them that there are times to eat, times to play and times to do their business. Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours.

How long can a puppy hold pee?

Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours. Don't go longer than this between bathroom breaks or they're guaranteed to have an accident.

How long can a puppy go at night without peeing?

Gradually, your puppy will build bladder control and should be able to sleep through the night without needing to go to the bathroom as frequently. A good rule of thumb is that puppies can usually hold their urine for their age in months plus one, converted to hours.

How long can a puppy go without peeing at night?

Gradually, your puppy will build bladder control and should be able to sleep through the night without needing to go to the bathroom as frequently. A good rule of thumb is that puppies can usually hold their urine for their age in months plus one, converted to hours.

The Secret Reason You Constantly Have to Pee

How Long Can dogs hold pee?

How Long Can Dogs Usually Hold Their Pee? There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

How long dogs can hold pee?

How Long Can Dogs Usually Hold Their Pee? There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

How Long Can dogs go without peeing at night?

Adult dogs typically need to go out every 6-8 hours at a minimum. Crate-trained dogs and those whose owners are frequently gone for longer hours may be able to hold for as much as 10-12 hours. This is, however, fairly uncommon and should not be expected of your dog.

How Long Can dogs hold their pee?

How Long Can Dogs Usually Hold Their Pee? There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

How long can humans hold their pee?

According to Focus Magazine, the average human bladder can hold about 400 to 600 milliliters of urine. The average person produces about 1,500 ml of urine every 24 hours, so it only takes nine or 10 hours before you're filled up and you've gotta go — bad.

How long can Yorkies hold their pee?

The general rule is that Yorkies can hold it 1 hour for each month of their life plus one. For example, a Yorkshire terrier puppy that is 2 months old will be able to hold it for about 3 hours. However, you should not count the last minute but rather than that take him out as often as you can or feel.

How long puppy can hold pee?

Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours.

How long can a dog hold its pee or poop?

Don't let her hold it for more than 5-6 hours before she's one year old. Healthy adult dogs can hold their bladders up to eight, and even ten hours, when trained. However, you should take your dog outside more often than that, as holding for too long can cause incontinence and bladder stones.

How long can a dog hold its pee?

How Long Can Dogs Usually Hold Their Pee? There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

How long can a dog hold their pee overnight?

Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours.

How long can a dog hold his pee?

How Long Can Dogs Usually Hold Their Pee? There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

How long can Puppies hold their pee?

Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours.

How long can a dog hold their pee?

How Long Can Dogs Usually Hold Their Pee? There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

How long can a dog hold his pee and poop?

Don't let her hold it for more than 5-6 hours before she's one year old. Healthy adult dogs can hold their bladders up to eight, and even ten hours, when trained. However, you should take your dog outside more often than that, as holding for too long can cause incontinence and bladder stones.

How long can a puppy hold their pee?

Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours. Don't go longer than this between bathroom breaks or they're guaranteed to have an accident.

How long can a 3 month puppy hold their pee?

A puppy can hold their bladder for 30 to 45 minutes max at 2 months old. 1.5hrs to 2hrs at 3 months old, and an hour for each month of their age at 4 months old and older. Use this as a rule of thumb and you will be closer to reality.

How long can a 10 week old puppy hold its bladder at night?

10-12 weeks: Bladder capacity is increasing, but 2 hours is still the longest that most puppies can hold it at this stage. 3-6 months: At this point, consider the one hour per month rule. Three-month-old puppies can wait for three hours, four-month-old puppies for four hours, and so on.

How long can a puppy hold its pee?

The schedule teaches them that there are times to eat, times to play and times to do their business. Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours.

How long can a 10 week old puppy hold pee?

Generally, puppies can hold it for one hour per every month of age (so a three-month-old puppy can wait three hours to pee). Here are common time limits for puppies of different ages: 8-10 weeks: 1 hour or less.

How long can a 3 month old puppy hold its bladder at night?

Outside of a crate and roaming around with you in the home, I would say: A puppy can hold their bladder for 30 to 45 minutes max at 2 months old. 1.5hrs to 2hrs at 3 months old, and an hour for each month of their age at 4 months old and older.

How long can a 13 week old puppy hold pee?

Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours. Don't go longer than this between bathroom breaks or they're guaranteed to have an accident.

How long can a chihuahua hold their pee?

Remember that as the Chihuahua matures, hours will be added to the time that he can hold his needs. By the time a puppy is 6 to 8 months old, pee pads in the house will not be needed if home alone for 7 or 8 hours.

How long can little dogs hold their pee?

How Long Can Dogs Usually Hold Their Pee? There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

When can Puppy hold bladder at night?

Most rescue organizations [and breeders] don't have the capacity or resources to keep puppies a long time. They're usually taken from their mothers at only eight weeks,” she says. The good news is it's easier than you think to get your new puppy sleeping through the night.

How much pee Can a dog hold?

It's been found that dogs pass 10 - 20 ml of urine per every pound of their weight daily. Most adult dogs can go 8 – 10 hours without urinating, but this mainly depends on their age, sex, body size, and overall health. Smaller and younger dogs need to urinate more often than older, larger dogs.

How can dogs hold their pee so long?

How Long Can Puppies Hold Their Urine? Puppies can't hold their bladder as long as adults. If your new puppy is two months old, it shouldn't hold urine for longer than 3 hours. More so, young ones won't show they want outside; they will just pee whenever they feel like it.

How long can small dogs hold their pee?

How Long Can Dogs Usually Hold Their Pee? There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

How long can 1 year old dog hold pee?

There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

How long should a dog hold their pee?

How Long Can Dogs Usually Hold Their Pee? There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

How long can golden retrievers hold their pee?

There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

How long can husky puppies hold their pee?

Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours.

How long can a 3 month old puppy go without peeing at night?

In other words, a 3-month-old puppy can generally go four hours without urinating. So, if you sleep for eight hours, you'll need to get up once during the night to let your 3-month-old puppy out to pee.

HOW LONG CAN 5 month old puppy hold pee?

So, for example, a 3-month old puppy should be able to hold its urine for approximately 4 hours in a pinch. This means that if you have a properly toilet trained 4-month-old puppy that, theoretically, can hold its urine for 5 hours, and you shut that puppy in a crate for 6 or 7 hours, you are courting disaster.

How long can you crate a dog at night?

A good general rule to follow is one hour in the crate for each month of age. A three-month-old puppy should be fine in the crate for three hours. Puppies should sleep in their crates at night, as this helps them learn to sleep through the night.

How long can a dog hold?

How Long Can Dogs Usually Hold Their Pee? There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

How long can a dog sleep at night?

As shown in the accompanying infographic, the average dog will sleep 12-14 hours per day. If your dogs have adjusted to your sleep patterns, which most do eventually, they're sleeping around eight hours at night. So the other four to six hours required will occur during the day in the form of naps.

What happens if a dog holds his pee too long?

The same is true for dogs! However, having your dog 'hold it in' for long periods can lead to the development of bacteria in the accumulated urine. This can lead to a urinary tract infection or worse – a bladder or kidney infection. When a dog holds urine for long periods, bladder stones can form.

How long can a dog hold bladder?

How Long Can Dogs Usually Hold Their Pee? There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

At what age can dogs hold their pee?

Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours. Don't go longer than this between bathroom breaks or they're guaranteed to have an accident.

How long can Puppies sleep at night?

You can expect your puppy to sleep for about six to ten hours a night. By 16 weeks, they should have begun sleeping through the night. Daytime sleeping habits: Puppies sleep a lot during the day, just like babies. They are likely to sleep after a period of activity and then wake up refreshed, ready to play again.

How long can a dog hold poop?

Don't let her hold it for more than 5-6 hours before she's one year old. Healthy adult dogs can hold their bladders up to eight, and even ten hours, when trained. However, you should take your dog outside more often than that, as holding for too long can cause incontinence and bladder stones.

How do you stop a dog from peeing at night?

Make sure you give your dog one or two more potty breaks before heading to bed. Bring your pooch's bed in your room so you'll hear if he gets up. If your pup makes it through the night, be sure to get him outside first thing in the morning to relieve himself. After he “goes” in the right spot, praise him with a treat.

Why can dogs hold their pee so long?

When your dog spends years holding their urine they'll also eventually develop incontinence. This is because their bladder, which is a “holding reservoir,” becomes quite distended from holding their urine for so long over the course of many years.

How often do puppies pee at night?

Gradually, your puppy will build bladder control and should be able to sleep through the night without needing to go to the bathroom as frequently. A good rule of thumb is that puppies can usually hold their urine for their age in months plus one, converted to hours.

How long can a puppy be crated at night?

Puppies should never be crated for more than 8 hours at night, or during the day for more than the same number of hours as they are months old (so a 2 month old puppy should only be crated during the day for 2 hours at a time without a potty/play break.)

How long can a puppy hold poop?

Don't let her hold it for more than 5-6 hours before she's one year old. Healthy adult dogs can hold their bladders up to eight, and even ten hours, when trained. However, you should take your dog outside more often than that, as holding for too long can cause incontinence and bladder stones.

How often should a puppy pee at night?

Take your puppy outside for a bathroom break every one to two hours during the day. A general rule of thumb is that a puppy can hold it for as many hours as she is months old, plus one–for a three-month-old pup, that's four hours.

How long can a 10 week old puppy hold its pee?

Generally, puppies can hold it for one hour per every month of age (so a three-month-old puppy can wait three hours to pee). Here are common time limits for puppies of different ages: 8-10 weeks: 1 hour or less.

How long can a 5 month old puppy hold its pee?

So, for example, a 3-month old puppy should be able to hold its urine for approximately 4 hours in a pinch. This means that if you have a properly toilet trained 4-month-old puppy that, theoretically, can hold its urine for 5 hours, and you shut that puppy in a crate for 6 or 7 hours, you are courting disaster.

How long do dogs sleep at night?

As shown in the accompanying infographic, the average dog will sleep 12-14 hours per day. If your dogs have adjusted to your sleep patterns, which most do eventually, they're sleeping around eight hours at night. So the other four to six hours required will occur during the day in the form of naps.

How long can a 9 week old puppy hold its pee?

Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours. Don't go longer than this between bathroom breaks or they're guaranteed to have an accident.

How long can a 10 week old puppy hold his pee?

8-10 weeks: 1 hour or less. Puppies this young simply can't hold their urine for more than an hour, and even that is pushing it, sometimes! You might start crate training at this age, but you can't leave a young puppy in a crate for long periods; he'll wet his bed (a lot!)

Can dogs hold their pee?

How Long Can Puppies Hold Their Urine? Puppies can't hold their bladder as long as adults. If your new puppy is two months old, it shouldn't hold urine for longer than 3 hours. More so, young ones won't show they want outside; they will just pee whenever they feel like it.

How often does a puppy pee at night?

Gradually, your puppy will build bladder control and should be able to sleep through the night without needing to go to the bathroom as frequently. A good rule of thumb is that puppies can usually hold their urine for their age in months plus one, converted to hours.

How long do dogs cry at night?

Some puppies cry every night for the first one or two weeks while others only cry the first few nights. Your puppy might cry the entire night or he might only cry for an hour or so until he passes out. They are all different. Some puppies whimper softly and some scream and carry on like they're being harmed!

How long can a puppy hold it?

Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours. Don't go longer than this between bathroom breaks or they're guaranteed to have an accident.

How long can a cop hold you?

The police can hold you for up to 24 hours before they have to charge you with a crime or release you. They can apply to hold you for up to 36 or 96 hours if you're suspected of a serious crime, eg murder. You can be held without charge for up to 14 days If you're arrested under the Terrorism Act.

Do puppies pee at night?

Gradually, your puppy will build bladder control and should be able to sleep through the night without needing to go to the bathroom as frequently. A good rule of thumb is that puppies can usually hold their urine for their age in months plus one, converted to hours.

How old before a puppy can hold it all night?

The schedule teaches them that there are times to eat, times to play and times to do their business. Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours.

How long can a dog hold a poop?

Don't let her hold it for more than 5-6 hours before she's one year old. Healthy adult dogs can hold their bladders up to eight, and even ten hours, when trained. However, you should take your dog outside more often than that, as holding for too long can cause incontinence and bladder stones.

How Long Can dogs go without water at night?

It depends on a lot of health and physical factors. A healthy dog can go anywhere from 3 days to 1 week before they would pass. However they will start to crave water after half a day of going without. By 24 hours they are desperate for water.

Can puppies hold pee overnight?

A good rule of thumb is that puppies can usually hold their urine for their age in months plus one, converted to hours. So, if you sleep for eight hours, you'll need to get up once during the night to let your 3-month-old puppy out to pee.

How long should you crate a dog at night?

Adult dogs shouldn't be left in crates for more than 6-8 hours. Puppies of 17 weeks and older can handle up to 4 or 5 hours in a crate at a time. Leaving a dog home alone in a crate longer than this can hurt their mental and physical health.

Do dogs need to pee at night?

Puppies like children often need to pee or potty in the middle of the night. This need will diminish as your dog gets older. Some foods with a lot of fillers can produce larger or more frequent BMs and drinking water too late at night might be a problem. Also check with a vet for possible urinary tract infections.

How long does a dog sleep at night?

As shown in the accompanying infographic, the average dog will sleep 12-14 hours per day. If your dogs have adjusted to your sleep patterns, which most do eventually, they're sleeping around eight hours at night. So the other four to six hours required will occur during the day in the form of naps.

How long will a dog cry at night?

Some puppies cry every night for the first one or two weeks while others only cry the first few nights. Your puppy might cry the entire night or he might only cry for an hour or so until he passes out. They are all different. Some puppies whimper softly and some scream and carry on like they're being harmed!

How long should a dog sleep at night?

As shown in the accompanying infographic, the average dog will sleep 12-14 hours per day. If your dogs have adjusted to your sleep patterns, which most do eventually, they're sleeping around eight hours at night. So the other four to six hours required will occur during the day in the form of naps.

Why does my dog pee at night?

Sometimes it's just a matter of not being supervised before potty training is complete. Other times, your dog could be marking his territory in a spot that he previously peed on and can still smell. Another reason that younger pups have night time accidents has to do with when they eat and drink.

Why is my dog peeing at night?

Peeing inside at night can also be a sign that your dog isn't feeling so hot. It's a good idea to get a full check-up to make sure all is well before trying to train your dog out of this unpleasant habit. Remember, if you catch your pooch in the act of peeing inside, don't freak out!

How do I stop my dog peeing inside at night?

Make sure you give your dog one or two more potty breaks before heading to bed. Bring your pooch's bed in your room so you'll hear if he gets up. If your pup makes it through the night, be sure to get him outside first thing in the morning to relieve himself. After he “goes” in the right spot, praise him with a treat.

How do I stop my dog peeing at night?

Make sure you give your dog one or two more potty breaks before heading to bed. Bring your pooch's bed in your room so you'll hear if he gets up. If your pup makes it through the night, be sure to get him outside first thing in the morning to relieve himself. After he “goes” in the right spot, praise him with a treat.

How long can a dog hold a bowel movement?

Don't let her hold it for more than 5-6 hours before she's one year old. Healthy adult dogs can hold their bladders up to eight, and even ten hours, when trained. However, you should take your dog outside more often than that, as holding for too long can cause incontinence and bladder stones.

How do I stop my dog from peeing at night?

Make sure you give your dog one or two more potty breaks before heading to bed. Bring your pooch's bed in your room so you'll hear if he gets up. If your pup makes it through the night, be sure to get him outside first thing in the morning to relieve himself. After he “goes” in the right spot, praise him with a treat.

Can dogs get UTI from holding pee?

Holding in urine can cause toxins to back up, weaken the bladder muscles and more. The same is true for dogs! However, having your dog 'hold it in' for long periods can lead to the development of bacteria in the accumulated urine. This can lead to a urinary tract infection or worse – a bladder or kidney infection.

How long can a little dog hold its bladder?

How Long Can Dogs Usually Hold Their Pee? There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

How long can a dog hold its bladder overnight?

There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

How long should a dog hold it?

We can train them one way or another, but there's only so much we can do. Luckily, there's a general rule about how long they can hold their bladder. Canines can hold their pee from four to ten hours. Still, none should have to do it for longer than 8 hours.

How long can a puppy hold its bladder at 12 weeks?

10-12 weeks: Bladder capacity is increasing, but 2 hours is still the longest that most puppies can hold it at this stage. 3-6 months: At this point, consider the one hour per month rule. Three-month-old puppies can wait for three hours, four-month-old puppies for four hours, and so on.

How long can a puppy hold its bladder at 9 weeks?

Generally speaking, a puppy can control their bladder one hour for every month of age. So if your puppy is two months old, they can hold it for about two hours. Don't go longer than this between bathroom breaks or they're guaranteed to have an accident.

How long do puppies whine at night?

If you leave a puppy alone and don't respond to him at night at all, most puppies will eventually stop crying. For some puppies this can happen within a day or so. There are the puppies that sleep peacefully from the first night – but they usually belong to someone else. Most puppies take three or four days to adjust.

How Long Can dogs hold bladder?

How Long Can Dogs Usually Hold Their Pee? There is a general rule that you can follow about how long you can expect a dog to hold their urine. They can hold their urine or feces for one hour for every month old that they are - up to a maximum of 8 hours!

How long do puppies cry at night?

If you leave a puppy alone and don't respond to him at night at all, most puppies will eventually stop crying. For some puppies this can happen within a day or so. There are the puppies that sleep peacefully from the first night – but they usually belong to someone else. Most puppies take three or four days to adjust.

How long do puppies sleep at night?

Most puppies will sleep through the night by the time they're about 4 months (16 weeks) old. But with some help, diligence, and proactive training, you may be able to get your puppy there even earlier!

How long will puppy cry at night?

If you leave a puppy alone and don't respond to him at night at all, most puppies will eventually stop crying. For some puppies this can happen within a day or so. There are the puppies that sleep peacefully from the first night – but they usually belong to someone else. Most puppies take three or four days to adjust.

How long do puppys sleep at night?

You can expect your puppy to sleep for about six to ten hours a night. By 16 weeks, they should have begun sleeping through the night. Daytime sleeping habits: Puppies sleep a lot during the day, just like babies.

How long can I leave my puppy at night?

At 12 weeks old, most puppies need to go outside at least once during the night to go potty. Set yourself a gentle alarm four to five hours after your pup goes to bed so you can take him out. Try to avoid loud, obnoxious alarms, which can upset your puppy and cause him to potty in the crate.

How long can Puppy stay in crate at night?

Puppies under six months of age shouldn't stay in a crate for more than three or four hours at a time. They can't control their bladders and bowels for that long. The same goes for adult dogs being housetrained. Physically, an older dog can hold it, but they don't know they're supposed to.