Why do we feel empathy for animals?

Do Animals Feel Empathy?

Best Answer

Empathy is the ability to not only detect what others feel but also to experience that emotion yourself..

We humans can empathise with each other and other animals.

When we empathise, we 'feel into' others and understand how they feel.

It is thought that empathy is more likely to be present in social species.

What animals are thinking and feeling, and why it should matter | Carl Safina | TEDxMidAtlantic

Previous QuestionWhy do we love dogs so much?
Next QuestionHow long will my dog have diarrhea after changing food?

Related Questions

Why do humans feel empathy for animals?

Empathy is the ability to not only detect what others feel but also to experience that emotion yourself.. We humans can empathise with each other and other animals. When we empathise, we 'feel into' others and understand how they feel. Many people ascribe empathy to their dogs.

Why do humans feel empathy?

Empathy is important because it helps us understand how others are feeling so we can respond appropriately to the situation. It is typically associated with social behaviour and there is lots of research showing that greater empathy leads to more helping behaviour.

Do fish feel empathy?

Enpathy is something which is very close to humans. Animals dont feel thos emotion. We can debate on this but having studied animals both scietifically and pratically, it not empathy, its something else. In this article, they state that despite the evidence that fish feel pain, most people do not feel empathy for fish.

Animals Have Human Emotions

Do dogs feel empathy?

In the same manner that young humans show empathy and understanding of the emotions of others, so do dogs. Furthermore, we appear to have bred our dogs so that they not only show empathy, but also show sympathy, which is a desire to comfort others who might be in emotional distress.

Do rats feel empathy?

A new study finds rats prefer helping others over eating sweets. Detailed studies have shown that mice and chickens display empathy—and now we know rats do, too. © Tammy Stellanova. A study published recently has provided the first evidence of empathy-driven behavior in rodents.

Do animals feel pain like we do?

Pain is a complex experience involving sensory and emotional components: it is not just about how it feels, but also how it makes you feel. We know that animals certainly feel physical pain, but what is less clear is whether this emotional suffering that we feel can be said to be true of animals.

Are humans the only animals that feel empathy?

Share Do animals feel empathy? Throughout her career as a neurobiologist, Peggy Mason has been told over and over that the rats she experiments on are not capable of empathy. Only humans and other primates can understand the emotions of another. Most other animals can't.

Why do we feel bored?

People who lack self-awareness are more prone to boredom. A bored individual is unable to articulate what it is that he or she desires or wants to do. They have trouble describing their feelings. An inability to know what will make one happy can lead to a more profound existential boredom.

Do animals have empathy?

Why do we euthanize animals?

These animals may have been euthanized due to overcrowding, but may also have been sick, aggressive, injured or suffering from something else. More cats are euthanized than dogs because they are more likely to enter a shelter without any owner identification.

Why do we track animals?

Why Do Scientists Want to Track Animals via Satellite? Satellites allow scientists and researchers to apply new strategies to their study of wildlife, accumulating data without the risk of disturbing natural habitats.

Why do we groom animals?

There are many benefits to grooming your dog. As well as aerating the coat and ensuring healthy growth, brushing promotes good blood circulation. Grooming helps to keep grease levels down - a build-up of grease in a dog's coat can block pores and cause sebaceous cysts.

Why do we feel good after pooping?

Poo-phoria occurs when your bowel movement stimulates the vagus nerve, which descends from the brainstem to the colon. The poop authors write that it tends to take a particularly "large mass of stool" to trigger poo-phoria and its vagal-nerve-induced feelings of exhilaration, intense relaxation, and goose bumps.

Why do we vaccinate animals?

Vaccinating animals reduces animal suffering, reduces the transmission of microorganisms in the animal population, and is often more affordable than paying for the treatment of sick animals. Pets receive vaccines for infectious diseases such as rabies, parvovirus, distemper, and hepatitis.

Are Animals Empathetic?

Why do we love animals?

As the animals started to congregate around human settlements, they became more social, developing the communication skills needed to deal with other cats and humans. So, that's how we came to love animals, but it still doesn't really explain why. We can't love dogs and cats simply because of their utility.

Why do we tame animals?

Taming is the deliberate, human-directed process of training an animal against its initially wild or natural instincts to avoid (or attack) humans, so that it instead learns to become tolerant of humans. For example feral animals are domesticated, but not tamed.

Why do we quarantine animals?

They are the ones that have control over what happens to a quarantine animal. The main reason for the quarantine is to watch the animal for rabies. A virus found in the saliva of infected animals is what causes rabies. This can be transmitted to humans and other animals through a bite.

Why do we feel safe in bed?

Sleeping underneath your bedding make you feel safe and protected, which increases your brain's serotonin levels and decreases the presence of stress hormones. Scientific explanations aside, blankets are just plain soft and comfy. That's reason enough to get tucked in tonight.

Why do we need animals?

Why Are Animals Needed. Laboratory animals have organs and body systems similar to humans and other animals. In many cases, they are susceptible to the same diseases that affect humans. Because of this, the data derived from research on these animals can be applied directly to humans and to other animals as well.

Why we should use animals for testing?

Ethics committees exist to ensure that the potential benefits of research outweigh any suffering to the animals. Animal welfare is underpinned by the 3Rs – there is a legal requirement to replace animals with alternatives, refine experimental techniques and reduce the numbers of animals used in research.

Why do we need to rescue animals?

Animal shelters are way more than that, they help communities. Having animal shelters in the community is important because they provide homes for unwanted animals, provide people with new members to the family, and improve animal health. These animals need the love that they have lost when they came into the shelter.

Why do we keep pet animals?

Pets make socializing with others easier. Preventing boredom is another important reason to keep pets. An animal needs attention. It can need a lot of attention, as dogs do, but there are also animals that don't need as much attention, such as fish or turtles.

Why do we think animals are cute?

So our attraction to cute animals may be an evolutionary hangover, our minds being tricked by the features we see. We like baby animals because they look something like baby humans do, and we are biologically programmed to care for babies.

Why do we find animals cute?

The first is that humans find baby animals endearing simply because they find human babies so, and the two share many physical characteristics, such as large eyes, a rounded face, small nose and a plump, small body. This idea is supported by two studies, one in 2012 using kittens, the other in 2013 using puppies.

Why do we vaccinate our animals?

Vaccinating animals reduces animal suffering, reduces the transmission of microorganisms in the animal population, and is often more affordable than paying for the treatment of sick animals. Pets receive vaccines for infectious diseases such as rabies, parvovirus, distemper, and hepatitis.

Why should we do animal testing?

Testing on animals also serves to protect consumers, workers and the environment from the harmful effects of chemicals. All chemicals for commercial or personal use must be tested so that their effect on the people and animals exposed to them is understood.

What do we need animals for?

World Wildlife Day: Why We Need Wild Animals. Without plants and animals, our lives would not be possible. Oxygen, clean water and soil, and our earliest tools, food, and clothing came from flora and fauna. We domesticated some wild animals to become our livestock, providing milk, meat, and clothing.

Why should we euthanize animals?

“Limited admission” shelters are often called “no-kill” shelters because they do not euthanize. These shelters cannot accept any and all animals as they would be forced to euthanize because of the sheer number of animals that require housing.

Why we should save animals?

For maintaining a healthy ecological balance on this earth, animals, plants and marine species are as important as humans. But, sadly today, many of the animals and birds are getting endangered. The natural habitats of animals and plants are being destroyed for land development and farming by humans.

Why should we save animals?

Plants and trees filter our water and give us oxygen. Birds help to control pests and spread seeds. Bacteria and insects make soil more fertile so that crops can grow. Humans need many different animals for food and clothes and animals need other animals for food.

Why must we protect animals?

The conservation of endangered species is important for humans as well. A well-balanced ecosystem purifies the environment, giving us clean air to breathe, a healthy water system to support diverse marine life, and arable land for agricultural production. When ecosystems fail, our own health is at risk.

Why should we protect animals?

Why should we save endangered species? The health of an ecosystem is maintained by its plants and animals. A well-balanced ecosystem purifies the environment, giving us clean air to breathe, a healthy water system to support diverse marine life, and arable land for agricultural production.

Why should we help animals?

The conservation of endangered species is important for humans as well. A well-balanced ecosystem purifies the environment, giving us clean air to breathe, a healthy water system to support diverse marine life, and arable land for agricultural production.

Why we should protect animal?

Each organism on this earth has a role to play in the ecosystem but sadly many of the world's animals are gradually crowding up the endangered list due to habitat loss, illegal poaching, hunting, and so on. There are great factors contributing to wildlife extinction.

Do dogs feel pain like we do?

Dogs and Pain. Dogs feel pain to a similar extent as humans and can handle similar intensities of it. As a result, dogs often cope with varying tiers of pain in ways that people do. If a pooch experiences a certain amount of pain, he might exhibit clear malaise similar to that of a human.

Do dogs feel cold like we do?

Dogs do have fur coats, but it is of no help during a bitter cold. They are just as sensitive as people to a drop in the temperature. If the outside temperature falls below 50 ºF, small to medium-sized dogs begin to feel a cold nip. Larger dogs can, however, tolerate temperatures up to 40 ºF.

Why should we support animal welfare?

In so doing, animal welfare supports the use of animals by humans, and seeks to improve their treatment and well-being. We support the judicious, humane use of animals in biomedical research, higher education, and when necessary in product safety testing.

Why should we care about homeless animals?

Animal shelters are very important because they care for abandoned or neglected animals. They provide temporary homes for animals on the street. They also provide heath for sick wounded animals. They find homes for strays, and neglected and abused animals.

Why should we protect animal habitats?

Protect wildlife habitat. Logging, oil and gas drilling, over-grazing and development all result habitat destruction. Endangered species habitat should be protected and these impacts minimized. By protecting habitat, entire communities of animals and plants can be protected together.

Why should we care about animals?

The incidence and spread of animal diseases is affected by how animals are treated, and this can have very important effects. Similarly, during disasters caused by either natural or human-made events, outcomes for animals are important both in themselves and for their effects on humans and the environment.

Why should we care about animal extinction?

The Act provides a means to help preserve these species and their habitat for future generations. WHY SHOULD WE BE CONCERNED ABOUT THE LOSS OF SPECIES? Normally, new species develop, through a process known as speciation, at about the same rate that other species become extinct.

Why should we save endangered animals?

The health of an ecosystem is maintained by its plants and animals. When species become endangered, it is a sign of an ecosystem's imbalance. This balance is difficult to maintain: the loss of one species often triggers the loss of others. By saving endangered species, we are ultimately saving ourselves.

Why should we care about endangered animals?

Why should I care about endangered species? Studies have found that unchecked deforestation and species extinctions will directly impact human well-being. Even little-known species can provide surprising benefits for humans, such as drugs that combat cancer.

Do animals feel remorse?

While empathy and compassion may be common in animals, guilt may be a uniquely human emotion. A study published in the journal Behavioural Processes in 2009 found that dogs' guilty looks don't signal remorse. In the study, they told owners that their dogs had eaten a forbidden treat while the owners left the room.

Why do we keep pets and other animals at home?

Pets are comforting companions. They keep us healthy and relieve stress. They play and show us love. Studies show that there are more families with dogs than cats, but the total number of pet cats outnumbers dogs.

Do animals feel rhythm?

Every animal tested seems to have the same ability humans have to perceive pitch -- high or low sounds. No one knows why only humans and some animals have developed the ability to synchronize with rhythm, the scientists agree.

Do animals feel embarrassment?

Scientists know that animals can feel anger, sadness, fear, empathy and happiness. When it comes to the more subtle social emotions, like embarrassment, some experts believe that dogs and cats are capable of feeling humiliation, although it may not be the same way we feel it.

Why should we take care of animals?

We should take care of plants and animals because these jointly sustain life on the Earth. Plants provide the food and oxygen for the survival of animals and animals in return provide carbon dioxide to plants for photosynthesis. Survival of plants and animals is very important for the survival of humans on the Earth.

Do animals feel fear?

Animals feel intense fear when they're threatened in any way, regardless of whether they're predators or prey. While all animals can be overwhelmed by terror, prey animals like cows, deer, horses, and rabbits spend a lot more time being scared than predators do.

Do animals feel pleasure?

In fact the enjoyment of sex among humans and among animals may be similar in that it's all experienced in very primitive parts of the brain. Not only do animals enjoy the deed, they also likely have orgasms, he said. Bonobos and possibly dolphins also pursue sex recreationally, Bekoff said.

How do we protect animals?

Scientists tell us the best way to protect endangered species is to protect the special places where they live. Wildlife must have places to find food, shelter and raise their young. Parks, wildlife refuges, and other open space should be protected near your community.

Why do we test dogs for health?

Embark helps you care for your dog in a way that leads to a higher quality of life, for longer. Extend your dog's healthspan by testing for 170+ genetic diseases that occur later in life including glaucoma, degenerative myelopathy, and dilated cardiomyopathy, three of the most common adult-onset diseases in dogs.

Do animals understand and feel?

And it is these unpleasant feelings that cause the suffering we humans associate with pain. We know that animals certainly feel physical pain, but what is less clear is whether this emotional suffering that we feel can be said to be true of animals.

Do animals feel spicy food?

Cats have many heightened senses compared to humans, but taste is not one of them. They can sense spicy foods, but they're not good for them, so limit their chili intake. Other animals need to be able to sense starches and carbs for survival, but not cats. They do take temperature and texture into account at mealtime.

How do you express empathy?

To start using empathy more effectively, consider the following: Put aside your viewpoint, and try to see things from the other person's point of view. Validate the other person's perspective. Examine your attitude. Listen. Ask what the other person would do.

Do dogs feel the cold like we do?

On the other end of the spectrum, dogs do have fur and fat that help insulate their bodies, but they can still get too cold. One sign your dog may be too cold is if they start shaking. So, it's very important to make sure your dog's body temperature stays normal.

Should we protect animals?

There are many things we can do to help endangered animals, here are a few suggestions. Protect wildlife habitats. Habitat loss is one of the biggest causes of extinction. Do your bit to preserve wildlife habitats.

Do we still send animals into space?

Sending animals to space began as a way to make sure that human astronauts could survive in space at all. As spaceflight programs began to evolve in the 1960s and 1970s, space offered scientists the opportunity to "turn off" gravity, a variable they could never fully eliminate on Earth.

Why do we drool when we sleep?

Causes. Drooling or sialorrhea can occur during sleep. It is often the result of open-mouth posture from CNS depressants intake or sleeping on one's side. Sometimes while sleeping, saliva does not build up at the back of the throat and does not trigger the normal swallow reflex, leading to the condition.

Why do we fart before we poop?

A buildup of gas-producing foods and swallowed air during the day may make you more flatulent in the evening. Also, you're more likely to fart when the muscles in the intestines are stimulated. When you're about to have a bowel movement, for example, those muscles are moving stool to the rectum.

Why we should not keep wild animals as pets?

Keeping a wild animal in captivity is extremely stressful to the animal. To wild animals, people are the same as predators and are avoided and feared. It is very difficult to provide a wild animal with proper housing conditions that will meet all of its physical and psychological needs.

What do dogs feel when we pet them?

Many dogs enjoy being petted on the the chest, shoulder and base of the tail. Touch between a human and a dog can have therapeutic benefits for both species. In humans, petting a dog can trigger the release of the bonding hormone oxytocin.Feeling that fur can also lower your heart rate and blood pressure.

Why should we adopt animals instead of buying?

Each year, 2.7 million adoptable dogs and cats are euthanized in the United States, simply because too many pets come into shelters and too few people consider adoption when looking for a pet. The number of euthanized animals could be reduced dramatically if more people adopted pets instead of buying them.

Why should we keep wild animals as pets?

Wild Animals Are Difficult to Care For. The Humane Society of the United States strongly opposes keeping wild animals as pets — whether caught in the wild or bred in captivity — because few people can provide the care they require. Keeping wildlife in a house or on a small farm is illegal in most areas.

Why should we not keep animals in cages?

Cages are needed to keep them safe and also to protect humans from dangerous animals like lions, tigers and bears. Some people argue that animals may lose their natural instincts if they are kept in cages. But it wouldn't be a serious problem if they are well fed and kept in big cages.

Do animals feel pain when euthanized?

Many professionals believe that carnivorous animals, such as cats and dogs, do not “hide” their pain, rather pain simply doesn't bother them the same way it bothers humans. When discussing the decision to euthanize, we should be just as concerned about anxiety in our pet as we are about pain.

Do humans feel more pain than animals?

And it is these unpleasant feelings that cause the suffering we humans associate with pain. We know that animals certainly feel physical pain, but what is less clear is whether this emotional suffering that we feel can be said to be true of animals.

Do animals feel earthquakes before humans?

But precisely what animals sense, if they feel anything at all, is a mystery. One theory is that wild and domestic creatures feel the Earth vibrate before humans. Other ideas suggest they detect electrical changes in the air or gas released from the Earth. Earthquakes are a sudden phenomenon.

Why do we cremate?

Cremation is a more simple disposition method to plan than a burial funeral. This is because with a burial funeral you have to plan for more transportation services for the body as well as embalming and other body preservation methods. Cremated remains can be scattered or buried.

Why do we drool?

Causes. Drooling or sialorrhea can occur during sleep. It is often the result of open-mouth posture from CNS depressants intake or sleeping on one's side. Sometimes while sleeping, saliva does not build up at the back of the throat and does not trigger the normal swallow reflex, leading to the condition.

Why do we smile?

Smiling reduces stress that your body and mind feel, almost similar to getting good sleep, according to recent studies. And smiling helps to generate more positive emotions within you. That's why we often feel happier around children – they smile more. On average, they do so 400 times a day.

Why do we burp?

Sometimes eating or drinking too fast can cause indigestion, which can make a person burp because this can send extra air into the stomach. The same thing happens when you drink through a straw: extra air in = more burps out. Burping is almost never anything to worry about. Try to burp quietly and cover your mouth.

Why do we fart?

Why do we fart? Gases produced during the digestive process cause flatulence. The body produces intestinal gas as part of the process of digestion. It can also contain small amounts of other gases, such as hydrogen sulfide, which make farts smell bad.

Why do we sneeze?

The function of sneezing is to expel mucus containing irritants from the nasal cavity. A sneeze, or sternutation, is a semi-autonomous, convulsive expulsion of air from the lungs through the nose and mouth, usually caused by foreign particles irritating the nasal mucosa.

Do plants feel pain like animals?

Plants have no brain or central nervous system, which means they can't feel anything. But let's dive a bit deeper. Humans and animals perceive pain through sensory nerve cells. Even though plants don't have nervous systems, they can respond to stimuli.

Do animals feel pain when eaten alive?

Animals, in fact, actually do not bear the pain, as they usually die when they get eaten alive.

Do animals feel pain during childbirth?

Depends entirely on the animals. In general, though, MOST species of animals don't scream while giving birth, even if they are in pain - such a vocalization would attract the wrong sort of attention. Humans experience more pain than most species because our offspring have such enormous heads.

Can animals feel music?

Human music is completely incomprehensible to animals in the same sense as we react to it: at an emotional level. Most animals probably react to pitch, volume, rhythm, beat but as sounds not music. However, it seems that music that evokes emotion as with humans is possible but it will be species specific.

What animal feels pain?

Though it has been argued that most invertebrates do not feel pain, there is some evidence that invertebrates, especially the decapod crustaceans (e.g. crabs and lobsters) and cephalopods (e.g. octopuses), exhibit behavioural and physiological reactions indicating they may have the capacity for this experience.

Do animals feel fear like humans?

An animal in a state of panic can't function at all. Animals feel intense fear when they're threatened in any way, regardless of whether they're predators or prey. While all animals can be overwhelmed by terror, prey animals like cows, deer, horses, and rabbits spend a lot more time being scared than predators do.

Why do we yawn?

One is that when we are bored or tired, we just don't breathe as deeply as we usually do. As this theory goes, our bodies take in less oxygen because our breathing has slowed. Therefore, yawning helps us bring more oxygen into the blood and move more carbon dioxide out of the blood.

Why do we shudder?

These movements are called 'hypnic jerks'. Most people are also familiar with the random body 'shudder' that some people get. This is sometimes described as 'walking on someones grave' because of the way it moves quickly through the body. The occasional hypnic jerk or a body shudder are normal.

Why do we evaluate?

Improve program design and implementation. It is important to periodically assess and adapt your activities to ensure they are as effective as they can be. Evaluation can help you identify areas for improvement and ultimately help you realize your goals more efficiently.

Should we give animals rights?

Animals are sentient beings! They do not have a voice, us humans need to protect them and give them a voice and this is where the concept of animal rights is rooted. 2. Opponents of animal rights argue that animals do not think or reason on their own so much that they need no rights.

Should we save endangered animals?

Why should we save endangered species? The health of an ecosystem is maintained by its plants and animals. This is because elk, without the wolf as its predator, grazed more heavily on plants needed by beavers for winter survival. The conservation of endangered species is important for humans as well.

Why do we pet?

It turns out that when owners pet their dogs, it releases oxytocin in both animals. Oxytocin in humans has been shown to strengthen social bonds, and reduce blood pressure, stress, and anxiety. It generally makes you feel better.

Why do we bathe?

One purpose of bathing is for personal hygiene. It is a means of achieving cleanliness by washing away dead skin cells, dirt and soil, and a preventative measure to reduce the incidence and spread of disease. It also reduces body odors. Bathing creates a feeling of well-being and the physical appearance of cleanliness.

How can we save animals?

Check out our Top 10 Ways to Save Animals to get a jump-start on making a huge difference in the lives of animal everywhere: Go Vegan! ©iStock.com/Bryngelzon. Complete a Mission. Buy Cruelty-Free. Play a Game. Don't Support Animals in Entertainment. Stay Involved. Volunteer at Your Local Animal Shelter. Cut Out Dissection.

How can we protect animals?

Protect the Environment One of the easiest and most effective ways to help wildlife is to preserve the environment in which the animals live. Participate in or hold your own local trash clean-up to help protect the habitats of endangered species and other wildlife. Reduce, reuse, recycle! Save energy.

Why do we need carbon?

The scientific consensus is that human-induced greenhouse gas emissions are the primary cause of global warming, and that carbon dioxide is the most important of the anthropogenic GHGs. Carbon taxes are one of the policies available to governments to reduce GHG emissions.

Why do we sneeze twice?

5. It's quite normal to sneeze in twos or threes. Those "bad" particles trapped in the nasal passages and expelled by sneezes aren't exactly sprinting to the exit. It often takes more than one attempt to kick those irritants out, which can lead to multiple sneezes in a row, Everyday Health reported.

Why do we eat pig?

Eating pork products, which are loaded with artery-clogging cholesterol and saturated fat, is a good way to increase your waistline and increase your chances of developing deadly diseases such as heart disease, diabetes, arthritis, osteoporosis, Alzheimer's, asthma, and impotence.

Why do we own pets?

The animal serves people's need to cherish, love and fight boredom. But this is really a distressing reason for keeping a pet. The animal is a replacement for normal human contact, something that apparently is too much to summon in our individualistic society. Their pet keeps them from pining.

Why do we eat cows?

Why We Love Dogs, Eat Pigs, and Wear Cows: An Introduction to Carnism (2009) is a book by American social psychologist Melanie Joy about the belief system and psychology of meat eating, or "carnism". Joy coined the term carnism in 2001 and developed it in her doctoral dissertation in 2003.

Why do we like music?

We like music because it makes us feel good. Using magnetic resonance imaging they showed that people listening to pleasurable music had activated brain regions called the limbic and paralimbic areas, which are connected to euphoric reward responses, like those we experience from sex, good food and addictive drugs.

Why do we need pets?

Pets make socializing with others easier. Preventing boredom is another important reason to keep pets. An animal needs attention. It can need a lot of attention, as dogs do, but there are also animals that don't need as much attention, such as fish or turtles.

Why do we cremate dogs?

Pets can be cremated either in usual crematories or the ones that are specifically dedicated for pet cremations. During the process, a pet's body is placed in a cremation unit and subjected to high temperatures up to 1400-1800 degrees Fahrenheit.

Why do we vaccinate dogs?

Vaccinations protect your pet from several highly contagious diseases such as canine distemper, parvovirus infection and respiratory tract infections. It also protects against transmissible diseases such as rabies that also pose a risk to humans. Vaccination will not cure a pet that is already sick.

Why do we train dogs?

Training is an important part of any dog's life, and is important for several reasons. It provides mental stimulation which helps to keep your dog happy, and if combined with morning exercise your dog will be mentally and physically tired at the end and far more likely to sleep during the day.

Why do we celebrate wins?

Here are three reasons why celebrating your wins is so critically important to your success. When you celebrate, endorphins are released inside your body and you feel incredible. Simply put, the lack of celebration will lead to a feeling of emptiness that will result in less focus and decreased performance over time.

Why do we forget dreams?

WE FORGET almost all dreams soon after waking up. Our forgetfulness is generally attributed to neurochemical conditions in the brain that occur during REM sleep, a phase of sleep characterized by rapid eye movements and dreaming. But that may not be the whole story.